vetted ten.

Presto Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry Immersion Element Deep Fryer 05466 review

No. 3 of 10 in our deep fryers ranking · Updated · How we rank

Our verdict: The Presto Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry Immersion Element Deep Fryer 05466 ranks 3rd of the 10 deep fryers we compare, with 9.0 out of 10.

Presto Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry Immersion Element Deep Fryer 05466

Presto Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry Immersion Element Deep Fryer 05466

9.0/10

The Presto 05466 is a stainless steel countertop fryer with two oblong baskets, an 1800-watt immersion element and a 5-quart oil capacity. It suits people who fry big batches or two foods at once and have room to store it.

Check Price on Amazon

Why it's here

  • 1800-watt element and a signal light for when the oil is ready
  • Two baskets handle two foods at once or one large batch
  • Adjustable thermostat and a magnetic breakaway cord
  • Element and enameled pot lift out for cleaning

Keep in mind

  • Cleaning the element and pot is fiddly
  • Short cord limits where it can sit
  • Bulky and uses a lot of oil

Why the Presto Stainless Steel Dual scores 9.0

Each bar shows where it places among the 10 deep fryers in this guide, so a full bar is 1st of 10. How happy owners are counts for most of the score.

  • How happy owners are2nd of 10
  • How many rated it5th of 10
  • How new it is3rd of 10

Why it sits behind the Presto FryDaddy Electric Deep Fryer 05420

The Presto FryDaddy Electric Deep Fryer 05420 (9.1) edges the Presto Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry Immersion Element Deep Fryer 05466 (9.0) on the balance of all three parts.

About the Presto Stainless Steel Dual

The 05466 is a stainless steel fryer that runs on 120 volts. Its heating element sits in the oil rather than under the pot. Presto says this gives quick preheating and fast oil temperature recovery. An adjustable thermostat sets the heat, and a signal light tells you when the oil is ready.

Presto lists the food capacity at 12 cups and the oil capacity at 5 quarts. Two oblong baskets fit side by side, which suits large pieces of fish or chicken. You can fry two foods at the same time or load both baskets with one batch.

The heating element and the enameled pot lift out for cleaning. The cover works as a spatter shield, and a second cover with a filter is meant to cut spattering further. Presto says to take the cover off when frying french fries and other high-moisture foods. The fryer also steams and boils.

What owners report about the Presto Stainless Steel Dual

Owner feedback we could open for this exact model is limited, so this is a short picture. Owners like frying two foods at once or filling both baskets for a large batch. The baskets take big pieces of chicken and fish, and some owners report good fries, fried chicken and empanadas. They say it heats quickly, recovers its oil temperature fast and is cleaner and easier than frying in a stovetop pot.

The main complaint is temperature. Some owners say the oil never reaches the 375°F they wanted, with the light switching off at roughly 330 to 340°F by their own thermometers. They also say the dial is hard to trust, and the fryer has no built-in thermometer, so you need your own to check. One owner found that stirring the oil helped. One owner returned theirs because the food came out greasy and not crisp.

Owners also mention that it takes up a lot of counter space and needs about a gallon of oil. They say the oil can be strained and reused. The element and pot come out easily, and the oil reservoir lifts out of the housing. We found little on long-term durability.

Who the Presto Stainless Steel Dual suits

Buy it if you cook for a crowd and want a large oil capacity with two baskets. It fits wings, fish fillets and chicken pieces, and it also steams and boils. Plan on counter or storage space, and on buying a separate thermometer if you fry at exact temperatures.

Look elsewhere if you want a precise, easy-to-trust temperature, a timer or a small footprint. The Chefman 4.5 Liter Deep Fryer with Basket Strainer RJ07-45-SS has a timer and a lid window. The Breville BDF500XL Smart Fryer is programmable. For a small, cheap fryer, the Presto FryDaddy Electric Deep Fryer 05420 is the simpler pick.

Questions about the Presto Stainless Steel Dual

How much oil does the Presto 05466 deep fryer hold?

Presto lists the oil capacity at 5 quarts. Owners say it needs about a gallon of oil, and the oil can be strained and reused.

How many cups of food does the Presto 05466 ProFry hold?

12 cups, per Presto. The two oblong baskets can be loaded with one large batch or with two different foods.

Does the Presto 05466 have a warranty?

Yes. Presto gives a one year limited warranty on it and links the full terms on its product page.

Do I take the cover off when frying french fries in the Presto 05466?

Yes. Presto says the cover must be off for french fries and other high-moisture foods. The cover works as a spatter shield for other foods.

Does the Presto 05466 get hot enough for 375°F?

Some owners say it does not. They measured about 330 to 340°F when the signal light went off. It has no built-in thermometer, so use your own to check.

Other deep fryer picks

The other badge winners in our deep fryers ranking.

The Presto Stainless Steel Dual on Amazon

Presto Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry Immersion Element Deep Fryer 05466

The Presto 05466 is a stainless steel countertop fryer with two oblong baskets, an 1800-watt immersion element and a 5-quart oil capacity. 9.0 out of 10.

Check Price on Amazon

How we score it

Every score here comes from our ranking model; no editor sets the order. We haven't read the review sites for this guide yet, so for now it is led by owners. It ranks products by how happy owners are, holding back any product few owners have rated until more agree. How many rated it and how new it is only settle close calls, and value for money earns its own badge rather than a higher place. We compared 16 models for this guide before settling on these ten.

Brands can't pay to be included or to move up. We last checked these picks in November 2026.

How we rank, in full