vetted ten.
Menu

KitchenAid Artisan Toaster 5KMT2204 review

No. 4 of 10 in our toasters ranking · Updated · How we rank

Our verdict: The KitchenAid Artisan Toaster 5KMT2204 ranks 4th of the 10 toasters we compare, with 8.2 out of 10.

KitchenAid Artisan Toaster 5KMT2204

8.2/10

The KitchenAid Artisan 5KMT2204 is a die-cast metal two-slot toaster that lowers and raises the bread itself. It suits a design-led kitchen with worktop space and a taste for a heavy, solid appliance.

Check Price on Amazon

Why it's here

  • Automatic lift and lower with a keep-warm function
  • Seven shade settings with an LED countdown
  • Includes a sandwich rack, with bagel and frozen modes
  • Cord wraps under the base, and a five-year guarantee

Keep in mind

  • The most expensive toaster in this list, for two slices
  • Heavy for its size, because of the die-cast body
  • Sandwich rack and fixed bagel mode add little if you only want plain toast

Why the KitchenAid 5KMT2204 scores 8.2

Each bar shows where it places among the 10 toasters in this guide, so a full bar is 1st of 10. How happy owners are counts for most of the score.

  • How happy owners are4th of 10
  • How many rated it4th of 10
  • How new it is7th of 10

Why it sits behind the Dualit Newgen 2 Slice Classic Toaster

The Dualit Newgen 2 Slice Classic Toaster (8.5) beats the KitchenAid Artisan Toaster 5KMT2204 (8.2) because it leaves owners clearly happier.

About the KitchenAid 5KMT2204

The 5KMT2204 has two extra-wide slots that centre the bread for even browning. When you put bread in, the toaster senses it and lowers it, then lifts it when done. An LED countdown shows the time left, and there are seven shade settings.

Beyond plain toast, there are sandwich, bagel, frozen and keep-warm modes. Keep-warm lowers the toast again to hold it warm if you step away. The body is die-cast metal, the crumb tray slides out, and the cord wraps away under the base.

It comes with a stainless steel sandwich rack. KitchenAid sells this model in Cast Iron Black, Imperial Grey, Candy Apple, Pebbled Palm, Pistachio, Ink Blue, Empire Red, Onyx Black, Medallion Silver and Almond Cream.

What owners report about the KitchenAid 5KMT2204

Owner feedback we could read for this model was thin. The one owner review we opened praised steady results across batches of toast and liked the keep-warm mode for when you get distracted.

We found nothing we could rely on about long-term durability or the crumb tray from owners of this model, so we say nothing on either.

Who the KitchenAid 5KMT2204 suits

This toaster suits someone who wants a solid, good-looking two-slice machine and likes the automatic lowering and the keep-warm mode. It is a sensible choice if the toaster lives on the worktop, since the die-cast body is heavy at 5 kg and has a footprint to match.

If you only want plain toast, the sandwich rack and fixed bagel mode add little, and a cheaper toaster will do the same job. For a family that needs more than two slices at once, the Dualit 4 Slot Lite Toaster or the Russell Hobbs Stylevia 4 Slice are better fits. For a similar motorised lift in a lighter package, look at the Cuisinart Smart Elite.

Questions about the KitchenAid 5KMT2204

What colours does the KitchenAid Artisan Toaster 5KMT2204 come in?

KitchenAid lists Cast Iron Black, Imperial Grey, Candy Apple, Pebbled Palm, Pistachio, Ink Blue, Empire Red, Onyx Black, Medallion Silver and Almond Cream. Not every colour is stocked by every retailer.

How big and heavy is the KitchenAid 5KMT2204?

About 22.5 cm high, 18 cm wide and 33 cm deep, and it weighs 5 kg. The die-cast metal body makes it heavier than most two-slice toasters.

What guarantee does the KitchenAid Artisan 5KMT2204 have?

KitchenAid lists it with a 5 years guarantee. A guarantee document is available to download from its page, so check it for any conditions.

Does the KitchenAid 5KMT2204 lower the bread by itself?

Yes. It senses the bread when you put it in, lowers it and starts toasting. Keep-warm mode lowers the toast again to hold it warm if you leave it.

Other toaster picks

The other badge winners in our toasters ranking.

All 10 toasters, compared

  1. 1 Smeg TSF01SSUK 2 Slice ToasterBest Choice 8.9 Check Price
  2. 2 Dualit 4 Slot Lite Toaster 46205 8.6 Check Price
  3. 3 Dualit Newgen 2 Slice Classic ToasterBest Premium 8.5 Check Price
  4. 4 KitchenAid Artisan Toaster 5KMT2204This review 8.2 Check Price
  5. 5 Russell Hobbs Stylevia 4 Slice Toaster 26292Value for Money 8.2 Check Price
  6. 6 Morphy Richards Signature Matt 4-Slice Toaster 245703 8.2 Check Price
  7. 7 Cuisinart Smart Elite 2-Slice Toaster CPT525U 7.9 Check Price
  8. 8 Breville Edge Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster VTR023 7.9 Check Price
  9. 9 Tower Solitaire 2 Slice Toaster T20082Best Budget 7.8 Check Price
  10. 10 Salter Alchemy 4-Slice Toaster EK5565BG 7.8 Check Price
See the full toasters ranking

The KitchenAid 5KMT2204 on Amazon

KitchenAid Artisan Toaster 5KMT2204

The KitchenAid Artisan 5KMT2204 is a die-cast metal two-slot toaster that lowers and raises the bread itself. 8.2 out of 10.

Check Price on Amazon

How we score it

Every score here comes from our ranking model; no editor sets the order. Too few review sites cover toasters for their verdicts to lead, so this ranking is led by owners. It ranks products by how happy owners are, holding back any product few owners have rated until more agree. How many rated it and how new it is only settle close calls, and value for money earns its own badge rather than a higher place. We compared 19 models for this guide before settling on these ten.

Brands can't pay to be included or to move up. We last checked these picks in November 2026.

How we rank, in full

Where these facts come from